top of page
Search

Span of Control in a Growing Company: What a Player-Coach Manager Can Realistically Carry

Writer: Milton Corsey
Milton Corsey
Nov 10
6 min read

In most middle-market companies, very few managers lead full time. The sales leader still carries a number. The engineering lead still ships code. The controller still closes the books every month while leading the team that helps close them. The org chart calls these people managers. Their calendars tell a more complicated story.


Most conversations about span of control count direct reports and stop there. For a player-coach, that number leaves out an entire second job. Here is how I help leadership teams work out what their working managers can realistically carry, and what to change when the answer is less than the org chart assumes.


The player-coach role most growing companies run on


How the role gets built


Nobody designs the player-coach role in a single meeting. It accumulates. A strong contributor takes on one direct report, then three, then seven, and their own workload never shrinks to make room. In a growing company there are good reasons it happens this way:

  • Their expertise is still needed on the work itself

  • A full-time manager can feel expensive at this size

  • Clients and colleagues still ask for them by name

  • They were promoted for what they produce


Each reason holds up on its own. Over time, the combination asks one person to do two jobs on a single calendar.


Two jobs, and only one gets measured


The individual work comes with deadlines, targets, and people who notice when it slips. The leadership work rarely does. Nobody sends a reminder when a one-on-one is skipped or a development conversation is postponed for the third month running. So when the week runs short, the measured job wins, and leadership becomes the flexible line in every calendar.

The doing gets done. The leading waits.


What working managers tell me in private


When I sit down with player-coaches one to one, I hear the same story in different words. They feel permanently behind on one job or the other. They lead their teams in the gaps, between client calls or after their own work is finished. Many are quietly proud of carrying both, and quietly worried that their people are getting the leftovers.


Why span of control looks different when the manager also carries a full workload


The org chart counts heads


Span of control is usually measured as the number of direct reports. That number matters, and it leaves out the variable that decides whether a manager can lead at all: how much of the week is available for leading. Seven direct reports with a full-time manager and seven with a manager who has a few spare hours a week are two very different teams.


What changes the load


Beyond headcount, four factors shape how many people a manager can realistically lead:

  • How much individual work they still own

  • How experienced the people on the team are

  • How similar the roles on the team are

  • How long the manager has been leading people


A team of experienced specialists doing similar work needs far less from its manager than a group of recent hires spread across different roles. The same span can be comfortable in one setting and impossible in another.


Count hours as well as heads


Here is a simple exercise I use with leadership teams. Estimate how much genuine attention each person on the team needs in a typical week, beyond group meetings: a one-on-one, some feedback, help getting unstuck, a conversation about growth. For the sake of the exercise, say it comes to about an hour per person. A manager with eight people then needs eight hours a week for leadership alone. If their own work already fills the week, those eight hours come out of evenings, or they do not happen. Presence is not performance. Presence is attention. And attention takes time.


The right figure will vary from team to team. The value is in doing the arithmetic, because most companies never have.


The signals that a manager's span has outgrown their week


An overloaded span rarely shows up in results first. The early signals appear in three places, usually months before performance slips.


Inside the manager's calendar


Look for patterns that repeat over several weeks:

  • One-on-ones moved more often than they happen

  • Feedback that arrives only when something goes wrong

  • Their own work being finished late in the evening

  • Decisions waiting in a queue for their approval


Any of these can happen in a hard month. When they become the normal shape of the week, the span has outgrown the calendar.


Across the team


The team adapts to an absent manager in predictable ways:

  • Questions go to peers because the manager is hard to reach

  • New hires take longer than expected to find their feet

  • Development conversations have not happened in months

  • Strong performers have gone noticeably quiet


None of these show up on a dashboard, which is why they tend to be noticed late.


In the manager's own steadiness


This is the signal leaders most often miss. A depleted manager becomes a reactive one. Self-Regulation, one of the Five Dimensions of Emotional Intelligence, is usually the first casualty of an overloaded week. Their patience shortens, their tone tightens, and small problems start to feel like interruptions. Teams sense that shift long before anyone mentions it, and they adjust by bringing fewer problems forward. At that point an overloaded span is costing the company information as well as time.


Protecting leadership time inside a working manager's calendar


Decide how the week divides


The most useful conversation a player-coach can have is with their own leader, about how much of the week belongs to the team. Put a number on it. Then adjust the individual targets to match, because an agreement to protect leadership time means very little while the quota stays the same.


Anchor a few routines that survive a bad week


A working manager cannot do everything a full-time manager would. They can protect a short list of routines that hold even in a busy week:

  • A one-on-one with each person at least every other week

  • One team conversation each week about priorities

  • Feedback within a few days of noticing something

  • A development conversation with each person every quarter


I teach the Five Leadership Conversations: Clarity, Coaching, Accountability, Recognition, and Repair. When a player-coach runs out of time, Coaching and Recognition go first, and they are the two people miss most. Repair rarely happens at all, because nobody notices the damage until it has already been done.


Give the individual work its own blocks


Leadership time gets fragmented when individual work is scattered across every hour of the day. Many working managers do better with two or three protected blocks for their own deliverables each week and open time around them for their people. The team learns when the manager is reachable, and the manager stops feeling interrupted by the very people they lead.


When to split a team, add a lead, or lighten the individual load


Routines help, though some spans have outgrown what any calendar can hold. At that point the answer is structural, and there are three main options.


Lighten the individual load


Move accounts, projects, or targets to other people so the manager has more of the week for leading. This works well when the manager is strong with people and the team is likely to keep growing. Someone has to absorb the work they hand over, which belongs in the headcount plan.


Add a lead


Name an experienced team member to handle day-to-day questions, technical guidance, and part of the onboarding, without making them a full manager. It eases the load quickly and doubles as a proving ground for a future leader.


Split the team


When a team has grown past what one person can see clearly, create a second leadership role. It is the most expensive option and often the most honest one, especially when the growth plan says the team will keep expanding.


Choosing between them


These questions usually point to the right move:

  • How hard is the manager's individual work to hand off?

  • Is someone on the team ready to take on part of the leading?

  • Will the team keep growing this year?

  • What does the manager want to be doing in two years?


That last question matters more than most leadership teams expect. Some player-coaches want to lead full time. Others would be happier, and more valuable, as senior experts with a lighter people role. Asking directly saves everyone a year of guessing.


If your managers are leading in the gaps of another full-time job, the fix is usually structural, and it is easier to make before the next wave of hiring. I work with leadership teams to assess spans of control across the manager layer, redesign the roles stretched furthest, and give working managers routines that hold up in a busy week. Book a workload review and we will start with the managers carrying the most.



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page